‘Smoke’ showrunner reveals why he dropped that major twist in Apple TV Plus’ new true crime thriller – 1v1 Video Chat & LIve Streaming & Influencer Subscription

Tom’s Guide

Search Tom’s Guide

View Profile

Newsletters

Best Picks

Entertainment

Prime Day Deals
Switch 2 Restock

Galaxy Z Fold 7
Wordle Today

Best Mattress
Best laptops

You may like

Apple TV Plus’ new sci-fi action comedy is definitely worth watching — there’s just one problem

Prime Video’s ‘The Sexiest Man in Winnipeg’ is a true crime train wreck — here’s why it still fascinated me

Netflix’s new crime thriller show should be your next binge-watch — and it’ll have you hooked from episode one

Taron Egerton’s character, David Gudsen, is an arson investigator who is also a serial arsonist.

To be fair, the show’s official trailer doesn’t entirely hide this. It avoids showing the reveal directly, but it’s clear that Detective Calderone (Jurnee Smollett) thinks her new partner could be a prolific arsonist.
So when I had a chance to sit down with showrunner Dennis Lehane (“The Wire,” “Black Bird”) to discuss the true crime limited series, I asked him about the choice to drop what would normally be a major reveal so early on in the show.
‘It’s not about the twist at all’
For his part, Lehane simply doesn’t want to deceive audiences just for the sake of shock value. Especially when, if you’ve already listened to “Firebug” anyway, you know who the arsonist in “Smoke” is likely to be.

Sign up to get the BEST of Tom’s Guide direct to your inbox.
Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsorsBy submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

We tried the third episode. We tried the second. We tried the first. And second just worked. Because it’s not about the twist at all. It’s about how deep does this rabbit hole of this guy’s mind go, and what are we going to find at the end of it?”Smoke” showrunner Dennis Lehane
“Audiences are so smart now, man,” Lehane rightly pointed out. “I hate shows when I’m sitting there, and I figured it out — I figure [it] out in episode 2, and you’re telling me in episode 6? It’s annoying.”
However, that doesn’t mean that the plan was always to go with a reveal at the end of the two-episode premiere. In fact, Lehane and the show’s creative team tried multiple options.
“We tried the third episode. We tried the second. We tried the first. And second just worked. Because it’s not about the twist at all. It’s about how deep does this rabbit hole of this guy’s mind go, and what are we going to find at the end of it?”

(Image credit: Apple TV Plus)
As someone who has seen “Smoke” and certainly thinks there are more than a few missteps in the miniseries’ nine-episode run, I have to agree with the decision to go with a reveal at the end of episode 2.
For starters, any further really would feel like the show is just dragging it out.
But given the premiere’s two-episode structure, it also leaves you on a high note. You walk away from the episode desperate to see what’s next now that you know the cat-and-mouse game between Calderone and Gudsen is afoot.
What is ‘Smoke’ about?

Smoke — Official Trailer | Apple TV+ – YouTube

As I’ve already mentioned on more than one occasion, “Smoke” is a true crime thriller miniseries based on the true crime podcast “Firebug.”
That podcast examined the life and crimes of John Leonard Orr, one of the most prolific arsonists in history.
In this show, showrunner Dennis Lehane has opted for a fictional stand-in, Pacific Northwest arson investigator Dave Gudsen (Taron Egerton). Along with Detective Michell Calderone (Jurnee Smollett), he’s part of a team chasing down a pair of serial arsonists.
But as you now know, one of the people they’re chasing is really Gudsen, and the show is, to quote Lehane, “not about the twist at all.” Instead, this show is a deep dive into the mind of more than a few twisted individuals as they investigate a spate of arson cases that lead to more than a few deaths.
Stream the first two episodes of “Smoke” on Apple TV Plus now

Malcolm McMillanStreaming Editor

Malcolm has been with Tom’s Guide since 2022, and has been covering the latest in streaming shows and movies since 2023. He’s not one to shy away from a hot take, including that “John Wick” is one of the four greatest films ever made.
Here’s what he’s been watching lately:

‘The Life of Chuck’ star discusses screening film with director Mike Flanagan, his favorite performances from the Stephen King adaptation and more
I just saw one of my favorite movies in theaters for its 40th anniversary — but you can stream it for free right now
Tom Hardy’s ‘MobLand’ just wrapped up with a stunning finale — and I can’t wait for a season 2

Streaming device deals not to miss

Roku Streaming Stick 4K (2021)

$44.40View
See all prices

Google Chromecast with Google TV

$55.99View
See all prices

Apple TV 4K (2022)

$135.49View
See all prices

Roku Express 4K+ (2021)

$28.96View
See all prices

Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max 2023

$64.48View
See all prices

We check over 250 million products every day for the best prices

Malcolm McMillan

Social Links Navigation
Streaming Editor

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Apple TV Plus’ new sci-fi action comedy is definitely worth watching — there’s just one problem

Prime Video’s ‘The Sexiest Man in Winnipeg’ is a true crime train wreck — here’s why it still fascinated me

Netflix’s new crime thriller show should be your next binge-watch — and it’ll have you hooked from episode one

Max’s new J.J. Abrams show is just the entertaining, action-packed ride I need right now

Apple TV Plus just dropped its new thriller movie — and it’s a gripping ride packed with twists you won’t expect

I just streamed Netflix’s chilling new murder mystery and haven’t been this hooked by a show in ages — you need to watch it now

Latest in Apple TV +

Apple TV Plus just dropped its new thriller movie — and it’s a gripping ride packed with twists you won’t expect

Apple teases ‘Slow Horses’ season 5 first look — and this ‘Ted Lasso’ star has joined the cast

I’d rather be golfing, but ‘Stick’ on Apple TV Plus was worth skipping a round for

‘Slow Horses’ season 5 release date just confirmed — here’s when it returns to Apple TV Plus

‘Your Friends and Neighbors’ season finale proves there are no consequences as long as you’re rich and look like Jon Hamm

Believe it: ‘Ted Lasso’ season 4 starts filming in July, says Hannah Waddingham

Latest in Features

2025 hiker’s gear guide — 9 pieces of outdoor gear I can’t live without

I used to repair phones — here’s the 3 things you should do when looking for a refurbished phone

College students, listen up! JLab’s new speakers are affordable, loud, and one can even be a portable karaoke machine

5 expert tips on how to declutter your home office — reduce stress and boost your focus

There’s a Netflix hack everyone should know — and it unlocks the full library

ChatGPT is reportedly building a Google Workspace and Microsoft Office rival — here’s what we know