By Editor Harry Wise
Car finance lender quits market after commissions scandal sparks industry upheaval
Secure Trust Bank intends to redirect capital to higher-returning businesses
By HARRY WISE
Updated: 09:59 BST, 2 July 2025
Secure Trust Bank plans to cease activity in the motor finance market to focus on more profitable business after the sector was rocked by a commissions scandal.
A watershed Court of Appeal ruling last October declared that lenders could not hand car dealers commissions without a customer’s informed consent.
Until 2021, most vehicle purchases involved the use of discretionary commission arrangements, which enabled dealerships and brokers to set the interest rate on a buyer’s finance agreement.
This incentivised brokers to charge consumers higher rates, regardless of other factors, such as the loan’s value, length of agreement, or a customer’s credit score.
The Court of Appeal’s decision has left the vehicle finance industry worried it might be hit with a huge compensation bill.
Ratings agency suggests the sector could end up paying 拢30billion, while one senior Financial Conduct Authority lawyer estimates it could surpass the 拢50billion banks paid to settle PPI claims.
Following an appeal against the October court decision, the Supreme Court is set to bring a final judgement on the matter sometime this month.
Pivot: Secure Trust Bank is halting all lending within its motor finance segment and allowing the existing portfolio to run off
Secure Trust told investors on Wednesday its commercial banking firm is halting all lending within the motor finance segment and allowing the existing portfolio to run off.
It claimed the move ‘reflects the historical financial performance and medium-term outlook’ of the vehicle finance division, which incurred a 拢21.8million loss before tax and exceptional items last year.
STB believes the pivot would have increased its adjusted pre-tax profits in 2024 from 拢39.1million to 拢56.6million and its return on average equity by 800 basis points.
RELATED ARTICLES
Court backs customers over lenders in multi-billion pound… Supreme Court to hear bombshell commission payments ruling…
Share this article
The Solihull-based company hopes to eliminate over 拢25million of operating costs by 2030 from running down its motor finance loan book.
Car finance claims dubbed the new PPI must not break the market, warns FCA
Over the same timeframe, 284 positions will be at risk of redundancy, including 78 this year alone.
The lender intends to redirect capital to more ‘higher-returning’ businesses, including retail finance, commercial finance, and real estate finance.
David McCreadie, chief executive of STB, said the ‘pivot will allow the group to prioritise these established specialist businesses and achieves further simplification of the group, combined with the removal of a significant level of costs.
‘These measures will have a material positive impact on ROAE for the group and will position the group to being capital accretive.’
‘We will be consulting with impacted colleagues to explain why this pivot in our strategy will drive the future sustainable success of the group.’
Secure Trust Bank shares were 6.8 per cent up at 852p on Wednesday morning and have climbed by around 140 per cent since the year started.
DIY INVESTING PLATFORMS
Easy investing and ready-made portfolios
Hargreaves Lansdown
Hargreaves Lansdown
Free fund dealing and investment ideas
interactive investor
interactive investor
Flat-fee investing from 拢4.99 per month
InvestEngine
InvestEngine
Account and trading fee-free ETF investing
Trading 212
Trading 212
Free share dealing and no account fee
Affiliate links: If you take out a product This is Money may earn a commission. These deals are chosen by our editorial team, as we think they are worth highlighting. This does not affect our editorial independence.
Compare the best investing account for you
Share or comment on this article:
Car finance lender quits market after commissions scandal sparks industry upheaval
Add comment